http://tacit.livejournal.com/373355.html"I've seen the idea that we are all responsible for our own emotional state become distorted by the Radical Honesty™ Effect in some parts of the poly community, where it seems to be taken as a code phrase for "I can do whatever I want to you, and no matter how it makes you feel, that's your shit to deal with, not mine.""This is something I ran in to about four years ago, and really had trouble dealing with. In principle, it made sense - it was just extending a virtuous principle (honesty), and making it "Radical." I couldn't really express why "Radical" seemed like a step in the wrong direction, how it seemed to take a virtue and turn it in to a negative.
It pretty thoroughly destroyed a relationship, because I felt like I was completely alone - there wasn't really any relationship there, just really awesome sex, wonderful adventures, and the
illusion that I had a caring, supportive partner. Excise the illusion, make it clear that emotional support wasn't part of the deal, and I think it would have been an amazing relationship, too. But it seems like part of the "Radical" philosophy is that it's a one way street: Radically Honest people don't want to be bluntly called an asshole, and Radically Responsible people seem to hate it when someone throws their shit back in their face and says "this is yours, YOU deal with it."
I think that's the line that keeps my own behaviour in check. If I'm going to feel comfortable with a certain level of self-responsibility or honesty, I have to be comfortable with it in BOTH directions. I also have to be fairly upfront and honest about it - I need to be able to explain it to someone who might not even be aware of the concept, someone who might not realize WHY this relationship isn't like the ones they've come to expect.
Forecasting my differences, making my style clear, so that people can make an informed decision, seems like a very central part of my life. I don't relate to people in particularly normal ways, and some people get really bothered by this. I've had partners freak out to discover they
didn't have veto power over my new relationships - in fact, I'd gone and started a relationship without even mentioning it for weeks. It's not that my way of doing things is "bad", just sometimes different and unexpected.
Setting proper expectations seems to be a very critical social skill in relationships, both romantic and in general :)