A little bit about how I use magic, and how that reconciles with "rationality." No particular point to this post. A few weeks ago there was an off-hand comment about being scientific and not being comfortable around ritual, and it got me thinking "but... I do science and ritual, and I don't find them at all conflicting!"
I suppose my big disclaimer to it all is that I'm entirely open to learning about new techniques, rational or magical, that work better. I don't "have faith" in my particular methods, even if they're ones I've spent years working with.
For that matter, I feel the same way about my rational beliefs too. It's all just theoretical models about how reality works - what matters is whether the model works
for my purposes. Gravity, after all, is 'just a theory.' It still got us to the moon and back :)
SuperstitionThe first is when I find something that happens to work. I have no rational basis for why it should work, and might even have my rational suspicions that it shouldn't work. However, with some reliability, fiddling with this arbitrary thing works. As an example, I've found that chaos is a good luck charm for me. I've found certain ways of fiddling with my computer seem to make it work better. I have a friend that yells at printers to make them work, and I listen to them and help them sort out their concerns.
I might investigate a possible rational cause, and will often even find a better solution. However, I've learned that the energy put in to finding a better solution is often far more energy than would go in to just accepting the situation and behaving superstitiously. So, unless I want to explore new solutions for the sake of curiousity, it's just not efficient to forgo my superstition. Some of them stick around simply because the cost is small enough, and it makes me happy to have them around (such as not picking up pennies that are showing tails, and grabbing pennies showing heads. I'm really not worried about 10 cents a month :))
PsychologicalBasically, magic is a useful metaphor for a lot of my intuition and other stuff that I just haven't developed a good "rational" language for. If I think about how someone's energy is prickly, and how they're a porcupine-totem, it helps me relate to them and know how to handle them. If I have an internal fantasy world, I can often study it and learn all sorts of interesting things about my subconscious from the unintentional patterns I leave in it (and sometimes the deliberate patterns are pretty telling too, when I actually pay attention)
I've seen a lot of people approach the practice of magic in this way. It's focused time to build self-awareness, intuition, and environmental awareness. Basically, we spend a lot of time fairly oblivious to large chunks of reality, and this is just a good way of grounding. These all seem like useful traits to me, even if they sometimes get wrapped up in superstition and kooky trappings.
Combining the twoSomewhat tied in to superstition, sometimes I just find that magical trappings work better for certain psychological changes. If I "aspect an element", it's a very easy coat-hook to hang "changing my behavior and personality" on, and it makes that transition much easier. It also makes it a lot easier to switch back. Sure, I could do the same thing by "focusing on shifting my emotions, reflecting on how to make my behavior match" but... well, it's just a much bulkier, less natural concept.
The last bit of that is that I often work with ideas that I'd have a lot of trouble expressing in language. I've had an idea for a game come to mind, and it took me two hours to actually find words to express it, to take it from an abstract concept and in to an actual description. It's similar to the effort involved in going from concept to finished painting. Sometimes I just don't want to go through the effort of "concretizing" an abstract or magical notion in to actual words. I can usually do it if I try, but it takes a long time to really find words that capture the nuances and vagarities of all that I'm thinking.